Brewing Customer Loyalty: The Power of Coffee Loyalty Programs

For coffee shops and other businesses, there are two driving factors for generating revenue: how many customers come to the store and how much customers purchase. Loyalty programs are incredible marketing tools because they forward both of these goals. 

When first-time customers learn your coffee shop has a loyalty program, they’re more likely to return a second time. They’re also more likely to buy something since each purchase is a stepping stone toward a specific goal, like a free coffee or bagel. 

Here’s more about the perks of a coffee customer loyalty program and why you should have one for your brand. 

Coffee Loyalty Programs Explained

What exactly is a coffee loyalty program? Like other loyalty programs, coffee loyalty programs operate on a simple principle: When the customer benefits the store, the store benefits the customer. A loyalty program creates a sense of partnership and benefits customers by giving them deals and a sense of community. 

When customers join a loyalty program at your store, they’ll feel like each purchase is an investment into their future. Conversely, loyalty programs for coffee shops can benefit you by generating revenue and encouraging return visits.

Types of Coffee Loyalty Programs

Although they’re all based on the same idea, the nuts and bolts of coffee shop loyalty programs can vary. Not every system for tracking customer engagement is the same, and rewards can also be different. Review these options to find the best system for you.

Points-Based Loyalty Programs

Many coffee loyalty programs operate off a points-based system. Customers can take different actions to gain points, and a certain number of points equals a certain reward. When customers earn enough, they can trade their existing points for the reward of their choice, and the process starts over. 

Points-based systems work because they keep customers focused on the next goal. They’re similar to video games, where the point counter is constantly changing and motivating players to reach their next goal.

Punch Card or Visit-Based Loyalty Programs

Another option for coffee shop loyalty programs is to use a punch card that records the number of purchases a customer makes. After a certain number of purchases, the customer will win a free drink or pastry, as noted on their card. 

Then, they can get a new card and start again. Punch cards let you know how often a certain customer comes back and offer motivation for them to return to the same shop. It’s a way to show appreciation for loyal customers while making a reasonable profit. 

Subscription-Based Loyalty Programs

If you use a subscription-based model, then your customers will pay an upfront fee for consistent perks. This type of membership subscription ensures you make a profit upfront while attracting customers to come back again and again. 

To work, subscription loyalty programs must offer enough value for customers to agree to your initial terms. For example, these programs could include a members-only discount on certain days of the week, access to members-only events, or dibs on choosing the name for seasonal drinks.

Mobile Apps and Digital Loyalty Programs

While some stores prefer to use a physical loyalty card, others opt for a digital loyalty program using an app. Mobile programs can be easier for customers to use because they can’t physically get lost, and they make points easy to access. 

The best option for you will depend on your customer base and the goals you have for your shop. Some people prefer the analog feel of physical cards, while others may see more benefit from using an online system. 

Understanding the Psychology of Loyalty

Why do loyalty programs work? The answer has to do with psychology. People are wired to go after goals, and they enjoy the feeling of exclusivity that comes with a loyalty program. 

Loyalty programs can also contribute to customers’ sense of identity and community. When customers join the loyalty program at your coffee shop, they’re forming a partnership with you that feels personal. Every time they shop at your store, they’ll be reminded they belong to your special club — they’re earning perks and opportunities unavailable to other customers. 

In a larger sense, coffee shops have become one of the most popular hubs for creating community. Loyal customers come back again and again, and they often bring their friends with them. On a psychological level, loyalty programs can increase the sense of community to encourage repeat visits.

Building Customer Relationships

As a coffee shop, your success depends on the relationships you cultivate in your community. Loyalty programs are one of many ways you can intentionally connect, give back, and learn more about your customers. 

Here are a few different ways loyalty programs build customer relationships: 

• They offer a personalized shopping experience.
• They show you value customers’ time and money.
• They open doors for email lists and other promotions.
• They enhance connections over social media.
• They allow you to collect data on patronage.

When you invest in your customers, they are more likely to invest back in you. Loyalty programs are a valuable way to connect with customers every time they come into your coffee shop. In addition, they’re the perfect segway into more connections via email, social media, and special events. 

Creating an Effective Coffee Loyalty Program

Now that you know more about coffee loyalty programs, it’s time to start creating your own. If you already have a program going, use these ideas to enhance and refine it. If you’re starting from scratch, here are several questions you can ask to create the best coffee loyalty program for your business: 

• What do my customers want from me? 
• How can I provide value for them?
• How can I make my program unique?

The most powerful loyalty programs adapt to customers’ changing needs. They reflect the unique mission and style of your store and align with your values. When customers join your program, they should feel good about themselves. 

After your program is in place, it’s essential to measure its success by collecting and analyzing data. Keep records of who participates, when they come into your store and what items they buy. With enough time and data, you’ll refine your program to make it even more valuable for you and your customers. 

Promote Your Coffee Brand with Joe’s Garage Coffee

Contact Us